Saturday, September 6, 2014

Reviewing a Political Science resource: Thinking about books



Harris, R. A., & Tichenor, D. J. (Eds.). (2010). A history of the U.S. political system: ideas, interests, and institutions (Vol. 1). Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO, LLC.

     Abortion in the United States


      Political Science is considered one of the core disciplines in the Arts and Sciences departments of American universities. Graduates in these programs not only work in government, they also find careers in business, at non-profits, and in research fields. Additionally, political science is one of the most popular undergraduate programs that feed into law schools. Resources designed specifically for political science students, like most materials written with a specific audience in mind, are equally valued by students in related fields: business, anthropology, history, and so on. Given the broad possible audience for such materials, it is important to assess this item based on who may use it more than who it may have been written for.

     The goal of this three volume collection is to use “original essays and primary documents” to explore the “ideas, institutions, and policies that have shaped” the U.S. government (ABC-CLIO). According to the description on the website, the first volume is specifically interested issues. These issues appear to encompass such topics as liberalism, religion, federalism, and the branches of government. The editors, Richard A. Harris and Daniel J. Tichenor, both hold PhDs and teach at Rutgers and the University of Oregon, respectively. The many authors who contributed to the work all hold similar credentials. 

     Volume 1 is both attractive and well organized. Each section of the work begins with a brief introduction that brings the reader up to speed on the topic. The section then presents two or three essays that discuss the topic in much greater depth. Finally, the section provides textual reproduction of primary document important to the topic covered. Images and tables are used sparingly which adds to the topic provided without cluttering up the clean presentation of information. Fortunately, the organizational style of the volume is consistent throughout making it easier to move between topics. It is also important to note that navigating to a specific bit of information is made easier thanks to a robust table of contents and index.

     The original essays in this volume are informative and easy to follow. If the reader is unfamiliar with some aspect of the essay, jumping to a primary source in the same section should help. Additionally, the essays are cited and provide suggestions for further reading. Perhaps the best news, of the essays examined, is that they are presented without a heavy reliance on jargon or partisan dogma. This helps make the work useful to a wide audience no matter their major or political disposition.

     I was, over all, quite impressed with this volume and hold high hopes that the other two in the series are just as well done. The publisher describes this series as the “first comprehensive resource” that “combines the tools of the political scientist and the historian” (ABC-CLIO). While this claim may smack of hyperbole, what cannot be argued is that lives up to its goal to give the reader a better understanding of the ideas, interests, and institutions that have influenced the U.S. political system.


No comments:

Post a Comment