Of the many other departments we have discussed in the social sciences, Communications is perhaps the most unique. History has great breadth and depth; anthropology is an umbrella for several different methods of study; and sociology and psychology are just a group of people away from being really similar. What makes communications different is that people both on the inside and outside argue what the field actually consists of. As Dawn Popoff commented in her article, "
Building and maintaining a journal collection in communication studies is complicated by a lack of agreement on what communication is" (source). The description of the field on our class page gave one description (and a good one) of communications:
Communication
studies integrates aspects of both social sciences and the humanities.
As a social science, the discipline often overlaps with sociology,
psychology, anthropology, biology, political science, economics, and
public policy, among others. From a humanities perspective,
communication is concerned with rhetoric and persuasion (traditional
graduate programs in communication studies trace their history to the
rhetoricians of Ancient Greece). The field applies to outside
disciplines as well, including engineering, architecture, mathematics,
and information science.
Of course, however, this brings me back to the field of history. While the vast majority of universities seems to put history in their schools of humanities---despite the fact that most historians have yet to decide if the discipline falls in the humanities, the social sciences, or both---it seems that there is the same straddling of schools by communications yet I have not found an instance of communications being considered a humanity. (Okay, I did find a few now, but it certainly doesn't seem to carry the same level of contention as the debate about history.)
Back on track:
It seems that, despite the fact that schools of library and information are often tied to or encapsulated by schools of communication, there is not a lot in the way of resources for communications provided by libraries. Part of this issue may go back to the previously mentioned article by Popoff who felt that the dearth of scholarly work led to a lack of academic journals, which follows a world with less dedicated databases for communications. Our library only lists three communications-specific databases, though it does recommend seven tangentially associated databases for users to try. Given that most who pursue this type of degree spend time making content rather than conducting research this reality seems to follow, however, that is still surprising as a recent study found that communications degrees were a part of the highest conferred degree category in 2012-2013 (source).
Sunday, October 26, 2014
Reviewing a Communications Resource: Thinking about books
Blanchard, M. A. (Ed.). (1998). History
of the Mass Media in the United States: an Encyclopedia. Chicago:
Routledge.
The demesne of mass media has expanded greatly following the
wide adoption of the Internet and the rise of the Information Age. In fact,
most social critics have argued that modern Americans may be the most media savvy
people ever. Of course, understanding what the media is doing right now does
not necessarily equate to an understanding of the history of mass media or the
minutia of the subject. What is needed for people who either want or need to
learn more is an excellent and easy to use reference source. This is that
source.
Edited by Dr. Margaret A. Blanchard, the former
distinguished professor of media history and First Amendment scholar at the
University of North Carolina, this volume has received glowing praise from
reviewers both in Booklist and Choice.
This volume chronicles the entire history of mass media in
the United States. From the first movable type press in the country to the
fledgling cable news channels that would come to dominate the 21st
century: this book has it all. Despite its impressive breadth, the book is easy
to navigate. The book provides access
through an alphabetical list of the entries or with a topical list. The latter
allows for differentiation is a single term may contain different meanings. There
is also an index and a guide to commonly used terms and abbreviations provided.
The volume is highly accessible and quickly searchable with minimal-to-no fuss.
The entries themselves are excellent. Each is copiously
researched and highly informative. Aside from the occasional anachronistic or
specialized term (which is addressed by the guide to terms and abbreviations) the
entries are readable and understandable. Where appropriate the work makes use
of photographs, images, illustrations, and facsimiles to further enhance
entries. Each entry provides its author and suggestions for further reading.
There is also an attempt at cross-referencing entries within the work by adding
a see also list at the end of each
entry. It is good that this was done, however, it is my opinion that
cross-referencing works better when done in the text rather than at the end. Of
course, this is sometimes difficult when suggesting tangential entries that are
not specifically mentioned in the text.
It is strange to call an encyclopedia excellent but this is
pretty much the case. Students studying journalism or other forms of mass
communication will likely find this work highly useful; however, that is hardly
the extent of the audience. There is a lot here for students of history,
marketing, advertising, and many of the other social sciences and humanities.
Even in an academic world dominated by databases and Google searches this
volume shows how powerful a good, old fashioned, paper encyclopedia can be.
Thursday, October 16, 2014
Reviewing a Sociology Resource: Thinking about books
Edgar, A., & Sedgwick, P.
(Eds.). (2008). Routledge key guides: cultural theory: the key
concepts (2nd ed.). New York: Routledge.
Sociology and psychology have a great deal in common though professionals in either field would not likely agree. There is a joke about a sociologist and a psychologist at a party pretending that the other does not exist. In any case, the similarities are real: in most cases both disciplines use many of the same theoretical models and types of data with the difference being that sociology is more concerned with groups and psychology tends to study the individual. Much like other disciplines in the social sciences, sociology both influences, and borrows heavily from, other fields. One of the important tools for sociologists, due to their focus on groups, is the understanding and application of cultural theory.
This work essentially amounts to a dictionary of concepts.
While this may sound underwhelming at first, the genius of this resource is in
how the reader can access the material. The front of the book offers two points
of access: an alphabetical list of the content and a list of contributors. The
back of the book offers two more: an index of names and a complete index. What
makes this so useful you may ask? Imagine that you need to write about a
particular theory and you have forgotten its name; however, you do remember
that Ervin Goffman had something to do with it. By looking up Goffman in the
index of names in the back you can quickly discover everything in the work that
involves his work. In less than a minute you are reading the entry for the dramaturgical
model. There is also one final point of access in the book: when another
concept covered by the volume is presented in an entry the term is bolded. All
these access points allow the user to move quickly and intuitively through the
work to find the information that they need. This is the hallmark of a great
reference book.
Along with the other sections mention above, the work also
includes an extensive bibliography so that readers can take their research to
their original works.
Edgar and Sedgwick, the editors, have their name attached to
many books in the field. Many of these works were favorably received by both
academics and librarians.
Routledge is known as a premiere imprint in academic libraries.
Cultural Theory is another excellent
volume in their Key Guides series.
Some librarians may be concerned by the high cost of the volume ($120 hb) but
there is cheaper alternative ($33.95 pb) but this volume will end up being
heavily used by those in the departments of sociology, geography, history and,
yes, even psychology.
Sunday, October 12, 2014
Geography: Stand in the place that you are, now think about other places
There are many great sources available online for people interested in or are studying geography. National Geographic has a great website for people of all ages. It offers news, articles, maps, games, videos and more covering the breadth of geoscience topics. Despite all the information available, the site does a great job of organizing the material. Pages can occasionally look a little cluttered but the overall experience is pleasant and navigation feels intuitive. The kids' section of the site is particularly robust and would serve as an excellent tool at home, the classroom, and at public libraries. Nat. Geo also offers a host of apps that look interesting but, unfortunately, are only available for iOS devices.
The Atlantic magazine offers a website called Citylab which, in many ways, could be described as a National Geographic for adults interested in life in metropolitan areas. Some of the articles, maps, and videos have a broader focus but the central theme of much of the material comes back to urban/suburban life. This site contains a lot of great information; it would be a great resource for public school students writing a paper but may not work as well for college students who tend to rely predominately on specialized databases and academic journals.
There are many great specialized tools available through Libguides as well as through popular media sites like Youtube and by searching Google. Geography students will also find resources designed for historians, sociologists, biologists, and urban scientists useful in their research. Post-graduates in geography will also require access to materials on theory that most people would not consider: for example, post-modernism.
A great resource for geoscience librarians, or for librarians looking to add to their understanding of the subject, is the Map and Geospatial Information Round Table (MAGRIT). This division of the American Library Association promotes information, understanding, and standardizing practices for subject librarians who work in geography.
Given the visual nature of much of its work, geography has found the Internet to be a highly effective delivery system for information about, and for, the discipline.
The Atlantic magazine offers a website called Citylab which, in many ways, could be described as a National Geographic for adults interested in life in metropolitan areas. Some of the articles, maps, and videos have a broader focus but the central theme of much of the material comes back to urban/suburban life. This site contains a lot of great information; it would be a great resource for public school students writing a paper but may not work as well for college students who tend to rely predominately on specialized databases and academic journals.
There are many great specialized tools available through Libguides as well as through popular media sites like Youtube and by searching Google. Geography students will also find resources designed for historians, sociologists, biologists, and urban scientists useful in their research. Post-graduates in geography will also require access to materials on theory that most people would not consider: for example, post-modernism.
A great resource for geoscience librarians, or for librarians looking to add to their understanding of the subject, is the Map and Geospatial Information Round Table (MAGRIT). This division of the American Library Association promotes information, understanding, and standardizing practices for subject librarians who work in geography.
Given the visual nature of much of its work, geography has found the Internet to be a highly effective delivery system for information about, and for, the discipline.
Reviewing a Geography Resource: Thinking about books
Moore, P. D. (2001). Ecosystem: Wetlands. New York: Facts on File, Inc.
A highly succinct translation of Geography is that it is ‘to
describe or write about the Earth’(source). This grand take on the subject is far from
hubris. Geographers study the environment, specific ecologies, humans, human
habitats, animals, animal habitats and, most important, the interplay between
them all. For this reason the resource requirements of geography have both
incredible breadth and depth.
This volume is one in a series that seeks to add greater
understanding and nuance to the natural world in which we live. The author
states that the goal of the work is to “explain who wetlands work, how and
where they develop, and what kinds of creatures dwell in them” (vii). He
contends that wetlands have and will continue to play a massively important
role to the environment and inhabitants of Earth. Peter D. Moore, the author,
is a professor at the University of California, Irvine. He has authored nearly
twenty works on nature, naturalism, and ecology.
The book is organized into ten chapters, or parts, which
explores the wetlands for many aspects. The geography, geology, chemistry,
economics, and history of the wetlands are just some of the topics touched in
the work. With glossy pages, high-quality photos, and colorful charts and
graphs the book does an excellent job of drawing the reader in. Further, this
approach allows people who learn best in different ways to find a way to engage
with the material. Along with the ten main chapters, a glossary of terms,
suggested reading lists, and an appendix that visually shows the geological
timescale is presented.
In writing this volume Moore seeks to cast a wide net. His
stated audience is “those who are interesting in knowing more about wetlands,
whether academic students of ecology or enthusiastic naturalists who wish to go
beyond the naming of plants and animals they encounter” (vii). This series of
books is designed with high school students in mind but much of the information
is usable and accessible to the groups that the author is targeting. First and
second year college students would find this as useful as any high school
student. For upper-division students and postgrads this book may seem too
simple or possibly even immature, but the solid facts and accessible
presentation could be a valuable tool in helping them to familiarize themselves
with a new topic or as a refresher to previously know information.
Sunday, October 5, 2014
Psychology: thinking about the people who think about people and what they think about
Psychology is the kind of discipline that generates a lot of information. Further, because some professional psychologists operate on a very small time table they often find it hard to locate what they need in the time that they have. In many ways this is also true of psychology students. Passive information requires an investment of users which they either may not know exists or find themselves quickly overwhelmed in the process of access and location. This is why experiments like the one at Capella University in 2007 is so important. A librarian was imbedded into introductory post-grad classes which led to remarkable results. The authors noted a 400% increase in reference transactions from individuals in these classes. Further, the imbedded librarian served as a facilitator who turned the information from passive to active. In the article that I discussed on Reddit this week, a similar experience was shown when a clinical librarian was embedded with mental health teams.
This is not to imply that a librarian needs to be embedded everywhere (though it couldn't hurt). Tools for users and information professionals continue to be refined and developed at a constant pace. In an article by Alice Perez (2005) she was able to speak of many forthcoming databases for psychology students and professionals. PsycCRITIQUES, an EBSCO database, contains the same robust tools as any other EBSCO db while focusing specifically on reviews of psychology books.
The American Psychological Association, the main professional organization of the profession, provides some many useful resources on its website. Especially valuable to information professionals is the Search Help and Training Center which provides information on searching PsycINFO databases. This page is also useful for psychology professionals and students who can access tools like the Presentation Archive, allowing them to experience presentation for which they were not present.
Sometimes when you do not, for whatever reason, have access to databases behind pay walls users will need to make use of free services. As the dominant search engine today, Google Scholar is likely a place where such users would head. Running a search for "library" and "psychology" led to results that likely don't fit the intent of the search. The search mostly returned articles about psychology that were served by libraries. Flipping the terms (as Google places greater importance on the left-most term) returns some different items, though the results are equally lackluster.
As with most other disciplines, psychology makes use of online tools like Youtube to present information and remote access to courses. Tools like Reddit are also popular. Looking at the psychology subreddit I was surprised to see most of the conversations having to do with cognitive psychology rather than psychoanalysis (which we tend to think of as the majority of psychologists). One thing that I did not notice on this subreddit that I saw on most of the others we have looked at were posts about people worrying about getting jobs. As to why there are so few libguides for psychology, are they too few? Libguides Community does not seem to provide a result count, but it would take 25 pages to print the results for psychology while history requires only 21. Anthropology, however, could be printed on only 16 pages.
This is not to imply that a librarian needs to be embedded everywhere (though it couldn't hurt). Tools for users and information professionals continue to be refined and developed at a constant pace. In an article by Alice Perez (2005) she was able to speak of many forthcoming databases for psychology students and professionals. PsycCRITIQUES, an EBSCO database, contains the same robust tools as any other EBSCO db while focusing specifically on reviews of psychology books.
The American Psychological Association, the main professional organization of the profession, provides some many useful resources on its website. Especially valuable to information professionals is the Search Help and Training Center which provides information on searching PsycINFO databases. This page is also useful for psychology professionals and students who can access tools like the Presentation Archive, allowing them to experience presentation for which they were not present.
Sometimes when you do not, for whatever reason, have access to databases behind pay walls users will need to make use of free services. As the dominant search engine today, Google Scholar is likely a place where such users would head. Running a search for "library" and "psychology" led to results that likely don't fit the intent of the search. The search mostly returned articles about psychology that were served by libraries. Flipping the terms (as Google places greater importance on the left-most term) returns some different items, though the results are equally lackluster.
As with most other disciplines, psychology makes use of online tools like Youtube to present information and remote access to courses. Tools like Reddit are also popular. Looking at the psychology subreddit I was surprised to see most of the conversations having to do with cognitive psychology rather than psychoanalysis (which we tend to think of as the majority of psychologists). One thing that I did not notice on this subreddit that I saw on most of the others we have looked at were posts about people worrying about getting jobs. As to why there are so few libguides for psychology, are they too few? Libguides Community does not seem to provide a result count, but it would take 25 pages to print the results for psychology while history requires only 21. Anthropology, however, could be printed on only 16 pages.
Saturday, October 4, 2014
Reviewing a Psychology Resource: Thinking about books
Landrum, R. E., & Davis, S. F. (2010). The Psychology
Major: Career Options and Strategies for Success (4th ed.). New York:
Prentice Hall.
Psychology is the field of study of the human mind. It seeks to understand what motives us, how we perceive the world around us, how to help us when things are not working properly, and so many more aspects of what social scientists have termed the human condition. The skills of psychologists are in demand throughout many sectors of the economy though they are mostly know for being psychoanalysts and professors of psychology in colleges. Given the breadth of career option open to psychology majors, a tool that explains the market to them would be an invaluable tool.
The authors of this book are both professors of psychology. Landrum served as chair of the Psychology Department at Boise State University for five years. His research includes creating measurement tools (surveys and questionnaires) to understand behavioral outcomes. Davis is professor emeritus at the Department of Psychology at Emporia State University who has been distinguished several times. He has been published in academic journal more than 300 times and has authored thirty-one books (source).
As stated previously, the goal of this book is to provide a resource for psychology students that both assists them in their academic work as well as show them the many occupation possibilities for people who hold a degree in psychology. This approach differentiates this book from similar works as most begin after the college experience. The book begins by looking at college itself: why you should or should not go; what is expected of you; what you should expect of yourself; and more. Not only was this chapter highly informative but it really speaks to college in general terms making it applicable for students considering any major. The next chapter is in roughly the same format as the first, but the focus now is specifically on the psychology major. The rest of the book covers career option based on degree attained, getting into graduate school, research and writing, citing and writing in APA, and advice on how to study.
The book is designed in a way that resembles a workbook. Inside the glossy, colorful cover are newsprint pages with black text and grey-scale images. It harkens back to Phonics books. This design was likely chosen to keep costs down (though the 5th edition sells for $41.20) though, more important, I think it encourages the reader to really interact with the information on the page: to take notes, to mark-up the supplied surveys, to really use the material. The book also makes great use of charts, tables, and examples that are all presently cleanly with pertinent information that rarely overwhelms.
Psychology majors will find this book invaluable. The first chapter is great for anybody considering or just entering college. In fact, with its focus on study strategies and consideration of college as-a-whole this book would be just as useful on the shelves of a high school or public library as it is in the reference section of academic libraries. If only the career guides for every major were this well done.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)