Of the many other departments we have discussed in the social sciences, Communications is perhaps the most unique. History has great breadth and depth; anthropology is an umbrella for several different methods of study; and sociology and psychology are just a group of people away from being really similar. What makes communications different is that people both on the inside and outside argue what the field actually consists of. As Dawn Popoff commented in her article, "
Building and maintaining a journal collection in communication studies is complicated by a lack of agreement on what communication is" (source). The description of the field on our class page gave one description (and a good one) of communications:
Communication
studies integrates aspects of both social sciences and the humanities.
As a social science, the discipline often overlaps with sociology,
psychology, anthropology, biology, political science, economics, and
public policy, among others. From a humanities perspective,
communication is concerned with rhetoric and persuasion (traditional
graduate programs in communication studies trace their history to the
rhetoricians of Ancient Greece). The field applies to outside
disciplines as well, including engineering, architecture, mathematics,
and information science.
Of course, however, this brings me back to the field of history. While the vast majority of universities seems to put history in their schools of humanities---despite the fact that most historians have yet to decide if the discipline falls in the humanities, the social sciences, or both---it seems that there is the same straddling of schools by communications yet I have not found an instance of communications being considered a humanity. (Okay, I did find a few now, but it certainly doesn't seem to carry the same level of contention as the debate about history.)
Back on track:
It seems that, despite the fact that schools of library and information are often tied to or encapsulated by schools of communication, there is not a lot in the way of resources for communications provided by libraries. Part of this issue may go back to the previously mentioned article by Popoff who felt that the dearth of scholarly work led to a lack of academic journals, which follows a world with less dedicated databases for communications. Our library only lists three communications-specific databases, though it does recommend seven tangentially associated databases for users to try. Given that most who pursue this type of degree spend time making content rather than conducting research this reality seems to follow, however, that is still surprising as a recent study found that communications degrees were a part of the highest conferred degree category in 2012-2013 (source).
No comments:
Post a Comment