Sunday, September 28, 2014

Thinking about Anthropology: It is complex



     Anthropology is fairly unique among academic disciplines. While it is common for a discipline to have different focuses, anthropology takes it a step further. Anthropology is in fact an umbrella that encompasses four related, yet different, fields: Sociocultural, Biological, Linguistic Anthropology and Archaeology. Further, within these four fields, there is a great many focuses and specialties. Not only is this confusing for the layman but it can greatly increase the difficultly for reference librarians trying to assist anthropologists and anthropology students.

     Not only does a reference librarian have to become familiar with the tools and terminology of anthropologists, but they also must seek out a broad collection of tools and resources for anthropologists to use. This process has been greatly helped by the growth of the Internet and online tools. Even then, as expressed by Wade Kotter in a 2005 article, that these tools are informative but have a long way to go before they become user friendly. Another aspect to consider is that anthropology resources will often range from the musculoskeletal structure of New World apes, the history of Egypt, Sanskrit, and pottery.

     More than just databases and eBooks, anthropologists have a strong presence on the Internet. As with most professions, anthropologists in the United States have a professional organization: American Anthropological Association.  With so many disciplines, fields, and focuses in anthropology the AAA is organized very similar to the American Library Association. Member will belong to the organization at large but also in a section or interest group that conforms better to their specific work. In addition to professional sites like this, anthropologists widely use blogs and videos as ways to discuss their profession and disseminate their work.

     Over the last few decades anthropologists have faced the same dilemma as many other fields that are considered predominately academic: a dearth of jobs. Because of this anthropologists have begun to successfully move into other work with for-profit and non-profit organizations. Some areas outside of the academe where anthropologists have excelled are in media, medicine, research, and advertising. This may add a further layer of complexity to the needs of anthropologists in libraries. 

     Anthropology is a complex field that requires a massive web of resources and support from reference services. While some tools may require more work before they are considered truly user-friendly, the fact that anthropologists have such a large presence online gives reference librarians a wealth of information to better serve this broad and diverse user base.

Reviewing an Anthropology Resource: Thinking about books

Brunvand, J. H. (2012). Encyclopedia of Urban Legends: Updated and Expanded Edition. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO, LLC.



     Anthropology is a complex discipline comprised of four parts: archaeological, cultural, linguistic, and biological.  Within the four fields are an enumerable and ever-expanding list of sub-disciplines and sub-sub-disciplines. At its heart however, anthropology want to understand the world and the people who live in it. Folklore and mythology have long held a place in that study as Western anthropologists tried to understand the the "strange" cultures they studied. In the last few decades, however, anthropologists have turned their attention to also include the societies that they call home. Urban legends are, part and parcel, the same as stories and legends from the deep Amazon: they are stories that explain the mores, values, and norms of the culture that also try to impart information. They are part of the folklore tradition.

     This work was compiled, edited, and written by Dr. Jan Harold Brunvand, a professor emeritus at the University of Utah's English Department. He wrote this book to create a tool for researches to use in their studies of folklore. The two volume set presents urban legends from all over the world. Each entry is not just one version of the story (as tales like this tend to change over time) but is a composite created from multiple iterations that is heavily cited. This is what changes the work for a compilation of spooky stories into a genuinely valuable tool for scholars.

     At the same time, however, the book plays to the inherent camp of the subject matter. Many entries feature illustration that bring to mind a graphic designer's re-imagining of Edward Gorey. This, along with the suggestive and salacious cover, does not detract from the scholarly value of the works but serves as a tool to invite more casual researchers and readers to read the volume. 

     Many works that cover folklore will often not give much time or credence to urban legends. In many cases it may be that the areas they are studying may not contain anything comparable to an urban environment; however, it seems that the exclusion has more to do with scholarly bias. As anthropologists spread out of the academe and find or create new positions in for-profit and non-profit institutions their research interests have continued to grow, morph, and turn back onto the cultures that they call home. This book is one of the rare instances of a work that is both scholarly and accessible. For anthropologists who believe that their craft is applicable anywhere, this is a valuable tool for studying modern folklore.

Sunday, September 21, 2014

Reviewing an Economics resource: Thinking about books



Clayton, G. E., & Giesbrecht, M. G. (2004). A guide to everyday economic statistics (6th ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill.

http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/41vzclIp0nL._SY300_.jpg

     Economics is a daunting subject for most people. Statistics, beyond the most rudimentary, can also quickly leave the majority of people confused. As the former relies heavily on the latter, you can imagine the response. Given the importance of the economy to everybody who is alive, it is important that people can learn to understand these concepts. Helping the laymen understand economic statistics if the very goal of the authors of this book.

     Clayton and Giesbrecht were both professors of economics at the University of Northern Kentucky when this book was published: Giesbrecht has since transitioned to emeritus status. Both men have received multiple awards and accreditations, and both have authored many well-regarded books and articles within their field.

     The book is cleanly organized and clearly written which makes it goal of teaching its concepts to unfamiliar readers much more likely. The book is divided into seven chapters. Each chapter explains a broad area of economics by providing several specific examples of statistics in that area. For example, Chapter Four deals with employment and income. One area that the authors focus on, as do most Americans, is the unemployment rate. Clayton and Giesbrecht explain how the data is collected, what the definition is of unemployment, the equation to find the percentage of unemployed, and finally some of the limitations inherent in this type of analysis. Despite the rather depressing nature of the topic, it was a joy to have it explain so simply as to be eloquent. 

     Aside from the clear, easy to comprehend writing style, the book also makes great use of visual aids. Charts and graphs appear consistently, reinforcing the ideas presented and also demonstrating how these statistics will likely appear in the wild. In addition to these visual aids, the book also includes several break-out boxes, or information panels, that explain how often such reports will be compiled, by whom, and how to go about finding the information (typically by going to a web site).

     The authors’ goal to teach complex concepts in a simple way proves quite successful. This is probably why the book made it to a sixth edition. Despite the clear and clean presentation this resource would probably best serve students of at least grade nine or higher. At the college level, this book should probably be required to any students whose field requires them to how to compile and read statistical studies. Further proof of the quality of this book is that, in 2010, a seventh edition was published.

Friday, September 19, 2014

A Potential Reference Librarian who hopes to Understand Economics

     As I began examining this field I quickly realized that I fell into a fairly common quagmire: I did not know the difference between Finance and Economics. The difference as expressed on a site designed for majors in these fields provided some easy to follow explanations. In summation, the main difference between the two appears to be twofold: education in Finance is thought to teach more practical skills and is a more desirable major for job recruiters. Obversely, while Economics still does a fair share of modeling, they type of work economists do is considered, at least in this conversation, to be more academic in purpose. This explanation seems fitting as economics is pretty much, in broadest terms, the study of people and the things that they use. While finance may better endear its students for the world of business, an economist could come up with compelling studies that study relationships that have no monetary aspect. It seems like a pretty interesting field of study.

     Professional organizations, as with most occupations and fields of study, are typically great places to find curated resources. The American Economic Association (AEA) offers many great resources for economics students and professionals. Valuable links to sites and information maintained by germane organizations such as the Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA), a division of the U.S. Department of Commerce. The BEA provides qualitative reports and studies that range from Regional to International. AEA resources also provide links to valuable secondary resources, such as Federal Reserve Archival System for Economic Research (FRASER) Reserve Archive who provide facsimiles of Presidential Economic Reports from 1947 to 2014. Secondary resources such as these are valuable for both economists as well as other social scientists.

     Up to this point we have looked at sources that considers economics very much through the aspect of money. As I stated above, this is only part of what economists look at in their work. One example comes from econlib.org. On a podcast available on the site, the host and an author have a lengthy conversation about public school education through the lens of economics. Much of the conversation bound through topics such as salaries, the culture of university education programs, and the perception of teachers by themselves and others. This was interesting to listen to as it really demonstrates how economic studies utilize terminologies and practices that are more readily associated with sociology, psychology, history, and anthropology.

     For students studying economics, one of the most useful tools they can turn to are LibGuides at their campus libraries. Since economics is such a broad field, it is important that these tools are as specific as possible to best help students. Here is a quick comparison. This first libguide states that books on economics will be found in the HA-HJ range. While this is technically correct, it could be improved on. This second libguide provides a more granular explanation of where books are located:


HB-HD   ECONOMICS

HB-HC      Economic Theory
HC            Economic History 
HG                             Finance
HJ                   Public Finance


Other relevant areas include:


HA                                            (Statistics)
HE  (Transportation and Communication)

HF                                          (Commerce)

KF                   (Federal Law and Policies)

J                                   (Political Science) 

The second libguide not only does a better job of explaining what books are available within each range but it also provides added information about related fields that may interest economics students. 

      Given the amazing depth and breadth of economics, it is important that tools designed to assist students are as informative as possible. For the first time in my life, I think I would like to read some more about economics.

Friday, September 12, 2014

History Students, Historians, and the Reference Desk (Oh my!)

     As a matter of full disclosure I feel it is important to admit that I am, in fact, a historian. I am not a professional historian—as there is nobody currently paying me—but I do hold both a BA and an MA in History. Further, I worked for two years as a TA at the Kent State Department of History and also spent many a sleepless night crafting my contribution to the field. Somebody in technical services even had the unenviable task of adding my thesis to KentLink.

All matters of personal history aside, on with the topic of the day.

     I believe that assisting history students and historians can be a daunting task for reference librarians who either spent little time in a post-secondary history classroom or, for whatever reason, simply hate history. As there is very little that I can comment the latter, I will instead do my best to elucidate those who may fall into the former.

     First I would like to address the sources that history students and historians (simply known as 'historians' from this point). Historians will make use of anything and everything. From government documents to the reports anthropologists; from diaries and journals to pieces of clothing; from furniture to newspapers; and from suits of armor to magazine ads—historians, much like anthropologists, take a holistic approach to their work. If, for example, a historian was researching the signing of the Declaration of Independence they could easily use all the resources listed above and countless more. In fact, were a librarian in a hurry simply tells such a historian that, "The history of the Americas can be found in the E-F range," that historian would have received little useful help.

     As I noted in an earlier post, historians tend to spend most of their time in a library looking at materials categorized in every section except History. The reason for this is two-fold: the intricacies of methodology and range of topic. Instead of speaking in generalities and risk losing point in ethereal vagaries, I will use my previously mentioned thesis as an example. Historians are well-versed in historiography—the study of writing in history—but when it comes to learning about methodology, much of what is taught comes from different professions: english, anthropology, sociology, psychology, etc. In my own case I created a paradigm of two theories, from two different schools of thought. Neither of these theories came from historians. Next it is necessary to consider the complexity of topics in historical research. What follows is the subject list from the catalog entry for my thesis:



Trials (Murder) -- Ohio -- Youngstown -- 19th century -- Case studies
Trials (Murder) -- Ohio -- Youngstown -- 19th century -- Public opinion -- Case studies
Murder -- Investigation -- Ohio -- Youngstown -- 19th century -- Case studies
Journalism -- Objectivity -- Ohio -- Youngstown -- 19th century -- Case studies
American newspapers -- Social aspects -- Ohio -- Youngstown -- 19th century -- Case studies

crime; murder; tramps; nineteenth-century; Youngstown; objectivity; executions; newspapers; sensationalism; narrative history; urban history

Sterling, Charles, -1877 -- Trials, litigation, etc

 
Now I am in no way an expert in all of these areas yet to write about the event that I was studying, I had to (quickly) develop enough contextual expertise in the law, journalism, labor, and criminal justice in order to test and support my argument. I spent a lot of time in libraries looking for resources created for lawyers, journalists, and sociologists. This has also been the case with many historians that I have known. Much of the in-field ready happens early and often leads them to their topic, but once they enter the research phase they will spend most of their time with primary sources and secondary sources from outside their field.

     Fortunately, most reference librarians will not have direct involvement with primary resources for historians as these are typically housed in archives. If there is one thing a historian will chew your ear off about it is their primary sources. Likely, and of you who looked at the history sub/reddit will have already noticed that.

     Academic reference librarians can feel out of their depth when presented with a student looking for information about liquid crystals, fluid dynamics, or any other subject we feel less than versed in. These moments are actually good things because they force us to ask more questions of the user to make sure we are giving them the right information. History, however, is something that most people think they know pretty well which may lead us to feel comfortable and question the user less. 

     After reading all this (I hope that I kept some of you until the end) just sit and ponder for a minute the hidden complexity and twists that could occur when a patron says, "I need sources for a history paper that I'm writing about the Declaration of Independence." The complexity of history is a good reminder of why we are continually reminded about and practicing our reference interview skills: because a question that seems simple is often the most difficult to answer.