Sunday, September 28, 2014

Reviewing an Anthropology Resource: Thinking about books

Brunvand, J. H. (2012). Encyclopedia of Urban Legends: Updated and Expanded Edition. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO, LLC.



     Anthropology is a complex discipline comprised of four parts: archaeological, cultural, linguistic, and biological.  Within the four fields are an enumerable and ever-expanding list of sub-disciplines and sub-sub-disciplines. At its heart however, anthropology want to understand the world and the people who live in it. Folklore and mythology have long held a place in that study as Western anthropologists tried to understand the the "strange" cultures they studied. In the last few decades, however, anthropologists have turned their attention to also include the societies that they call home. Urban legends are, part and parcel, the same as stories and legends from the deep Amazon: they are stories that explain the mores, values, and norms of the culture that also try to impart information. They are part of the folklore tradition.

     This work was compiled, edited, and written by Dr. Jan Harold Brunvand, a professor emeritus at the University of Utah's English Department. He wrote this book to create a tool for researches to use in their studies of folklore. The two volume set presents urban legends from all over the world. Each entry is not just one version of the story (as tales like this tend to change over time) but is a composite created from multiple iterations that is heavily cited. This is what changes the work for a compilation of spooky stories into a genuinely valuable tool for scholars.

     At the same time, however, the book plays to the inherent camp of the subject matter. Many entries feature illustration that bring to mind a graphic designer's re-imagining of Edward Gorey. This, along with the suggestive and salacious cover, does not detract from the scholarly value of the works but serves as a tool to invite more casual researchers and readers to read the volume. 

     Many works that cover folklore will often not give much time or credence to urban legends. In many cases it may be that the areas they are studying may not contain anything comparable to an urban environment; however, it seems that the exclusion has more to do with scholarly bias. As anthropologists spread out of the academe and find or create new positions in for-profit and non-profit institutions their research interests have continued to grow, morph, and turn back onto the cultures that they call home. This book is one of the rare instances of a work that is both scholarly and accessible. For anthropologists who believe that their craft is applicable anywhere, this is a valuable tool for studying modern folklore.

No comments:

Post a Comment